• 6 Posts
  • 841 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: March 3rd, 2025

help-circle



  • The story is about US Media failing to accurately cover Israel’s attack on a hospital

    by failing to scrutinize official accounting by US officials

    You keep leaving that pretty crucial piece out there kid. The larger story is about how US media is in bed with US state department interests - a relationship with an actual-fucking-textbook term: manufacturing consent

    And the reason why it’s important to continue making the problem known here is tbe same reason it was important for activists to show up to Harris/Biden rallies in 2023 protesting US complicity on Gaza. It’s the reason the tide has turned so hard that you have to sit here and pretend like there’s some procedural reason to cut Israel out of the US political conversation instead of just ignoring it entirely.

    God save you and the DNC for 2028, because noone else will.



  • Let’s not split hairs here, Jordan. They’re reporting on how US media reports on official White House accounting of international affairs, not the affairs themselves. US political actors (both US media and actual White House officials) are the actual subjects of this story, not Israel.

    You can complain all you want about the white house being pestered to give their accounting of events in Gaza at all, but it becomes US politics the moment they’re actively engaging in the discussion and the US media is centering them in their coverage. It’s certainly unflattering - i sympathize with why you might be frustrated by the topic, especially after how 2024 went and especially as we prepare for a 2028 campaign.

    Israel and Gaza are losing topics for democrats - that much is abundantly clear.






  • “Israel has a right to exist” and “Israel has a right to defend itself.”

    A huge part of the problem is that both of those statements lack any specificity - we can’t even have the conversation about whether any given state has some abstract ‘right’ to exist of defend itself if we don’t really have an agreed definition of what ‘Israel’ or a ‘state’ is, what ‘existence’ encompasses, and what limits to the definition of ‘defense’ we are operating under. Are we talking about Israel the geographic region, or the Jewish diaspora? Are we talking about a democratic state with religious and ethnic equality, or an apartheid two-class system of oppression?

    And that lack of specificity is almost the entire strategy of the democratic establishment and their position on the topic, and why the DNC consultant class and (apparently) smalltime internet forum moderators would rather dismiss all attempts of having that discussion



  • Jesus fuck you’re dense.

    A U.S. official with knowledge of American intelligence says Hamas has a command node under the Al-Shifa hospital…”

    “Like CNN, NBC News and ABC News similarly quoted White House officials claiming that Hamas had infiltrated hospitals, including Al-Shifa.”

    Western establishment media’s reliance on official assertions helped normalize what should have been unthinkable.”

    • U.S. officials making claims being used by Israel to justify war crimes
    • US new outlets, who broadly legitimize state department narratives on foreign conflicts and interests, reporting on those claims without validating them

    The irony of your editorializing in your moderation decisions would be far more entertaining to me if the reasoning for it weren’t so fucking transparent.